Eggs Should Not Go On Potato Salad, And Here’s 7 Reasons Why

  1. Flavor Fiasco
    Secondly, eggs have a sulphuric tang that can overpower the creamy mayo or zesty mustard, throwing off the overall flavor balance.
  2. Inclusivity Issue
    If you want everyone to enjoy your potato salad, skip the eggs. They can be a problem for people with digestion troubles or allergies. Adding them limits who can dig in.
  3. Not Vegan-Friendly
    For those eating clean or following a vegan lifestyle, eggs are a no-go. And while mayo often has eggs, you can find vegan versions at health stores.
  4. Shelf-Life Shortfall
    Potato salad with eggs doesn’t last as long. Potatoes, mustard, herbs, and mayo generally have a better shelf life. Eggs can cut the salad’s longevity and even pose a foodborne illness risk.
  5. Eggs Have Their Place
    Eggs really shine in egg salad. That’s where they can boost the flavor best, not in potato salad.
  6. Better Egg Options
    There are so many delicious things you can make with eggs, like frittatas, omelets, cakes, and pastries. Throwing them in potato salad seems like a waste.

Alternative Add-Ins for Potato Salad

Luckily, there are tons of other ingredients to jazz up your potato salad. Think bacon, different kinds of onions, garlic, parsley, dill, chives, or a splash of vinegar.

Potato salad is all about personal taste, but adding eggs might mean some folks can’t partake. With the flavor and texture changes, it’s often best to leave them out when you can.